When Sarah and Gavin first met, confusion wasn’t just in the air—it had a VIP seat.

Gavin had been invited to a Padres game as a last-minute substitute for a friend, thanks to their mutual friend Kristen. The plan was simple: meet up with Sarah and Carrie, enjoy the game, and call it a night. Easy, right? Not exactly.

The game ended, but that’s when things really began. Gavin walked away completely smitten—like, already-picturing-their-future smitten. Meanwhile, Sarah’s “gaydar” was going off at full volume. In her mind, she hadn’t just met a potential love interest… she had just met her new gay best friend. Iconic.

So there they were: Gavin thinking he was batting a perfect 1000, and Sarah blissfully unaware, already planning friendship bracelets.

But here’s the twist—because of that hilarious, all-time-great miscommunication, there were no nerves, no pressure, no trying to impress. Just two people being completely, authentically themselves. And somewhere between the laughter, the mix-ups, and the unexpected connection, something real started to grow.

Turns out, the best love stories don’t always start with perfect timing—they start with a little chaos, a lot of laughter, and maybe one person being very wrong about the situation.

And that one unforgettable Padres game? It led to a love story strong enough for not one, but two “I do’s.”